Backtesting & replay
Practise entries, stops and targets on historical candles and review simulated results in a separate private journal.
Sidebar → Backtesting & Replay, or Market Replay → Practice this window
See how it works →Trading journal comparisons · Updated 9 October 2026
CybillAI vs Edgewonk
Edgewonk advertises cloud access, psychology journaling, custom reports and a strategy lab. Compare that reflection workflow with CybillAI’s visual playbooks, weekly action checklist and selected-record mentor workspace.
Compare how each journal connects trading behaviour, strategy evidence and your review routine.
AI coaching included with Pro
No separate AI credit purchases or top-up charges.
Review, compare and practise in CybillAI
Explore the workflows now available in your journal.
Side-by-side performance comparisons
Compare saved strategies, broker accounts or date ranges through aligned P&L curves, outcome charts, recorded-risk distributions and automatic behaviour tags.
Advanced Analytics → Side-by-side
See how it works →Automatic tags & discipline review
Cybill classifies saved trades automatically, interprets relevant journal notes with quoted evidence, and shows visual behaviour patterns across your history.
Sidebar → Discipline Review, or Trades → Trade details → Cybill automatic tags
See how it works →Weekly reviews
Cybill keeps one continuing coaching focus, compares later recorded outcomes with a starting baseline, and connects your daily briefing with weekly progress. Optional review notes follow your account across devices.
Reports → Weekly review
See how it works →Private mentor workspaces
Choose the trades, annotated playbooks and weekly notes a mentor can review, discuss individual items privately and agree on process goals with revocable access.
Community → Mentorship, then Private workspace
See how it works →Risk & executions
See results in R, record contract values and review scale-ins and partial exits while preserving broker P&L.
Trades → View / Details → Risk & executions → Edit
See how it works →Visual playbooks
Build a setup library with private chart screenshots, numbered entry/exit markers, repeatable rules and actual strategy results.
Strategies → Visual playbooks
See how it works →Your dashboard, your layout
Choose the widgets you want, change their order and width, and save up to five personal dashboard layouts.
Dashboard → Overview → Customize
See how it works →Compare the workflows
Original competitor references were reviewed 6 October 2026; replay and AI-credit references were refreshed 9 October 2026. Availability varies by plan. Where official details are unclear, confirm the specific controls you need with the provider.
WorkflowCybillAIEdgewonk
Automatic tagging & discipline
CybillAI
Tags derived from saved trades, evidence-led discipline review, note-based AI candidates with confirmation or dismissal, and behaviour outcome charts. Available to signed-in journal users.
CybillAI guide →Edgewonk
Confirm which tags are created automatically, what evidence supports behaviour labels, and whether you can accept or dismiss them.
Official tagging and journal detailsSide-by-side performance
CybillAI
Pro comparisons of strategies, broker accounts or date ranges through aligned P&L curves, outcomes, recorded-risk distributions and behaviour-tag charts. Sample sizes and exclusions remain visible.
CybillAI guide →Edgewonk
Check the current strategy, account and date-range comparison controls, contributing-trade drilldowns and R-data requirements in your chosen plan.
Current comparison and plan detailsWeekly review
CybillAI
A saved Cybill coaching focus with a starting baseline and later outcome tracking, Monday–Sunday review charts, previous-week comparison, optional account-saved notes and checklists, and Markdown export.
CybillAI guide →Edgewonk
Review/report cards, an integrated diary and trade checklists are advertised. Compare how they fit your weekly routine.
Review and psychology featuresPrivate mentor collaboration
CybillAI
Accepted connections with explicitly selected trades, complete playbooks and weekly notes; item-specific comments, agreed goals and revocable access.
CybillAI guide →Edgewonk
Check mentor collaboration, sharing scope and available permissions directly with the provider.
Official product detailsVisual playbooks
CybillAI
Private screenshots, numbered entry/exit annotations, setup rules and performance from actual trades assigned to the strategy.
CybillAI guide →Edgewonk
A strategy lab and reports by setups and behaviour are advertised. Compare screenshot libraries and chart annotation workflows directly.
Strategy and reporting featuresPersonal dashboard
CybillAI
Choose, reorder and resize widgets; save up to five named layouts to your account.
CybillAI guide →Edgewonk
Customisable reports and journal settings are advertised. Check the dashboard arrangement and saved-view controls you need.
Customisation overviewCoaching and reflection
CybillAI
AI coaching included with Pro alongside journal analytics and weekly review prompts. No separate AI credit purchases or top-up charges. Recorded data and coverage determine which insights are available.
CybillAI guide →Edgewonk
Psychology journaling covers mistakes, emotions, checklists and qualitative factors connected to performance.
Psychology journal overviewReplay and execution context
CybillAI
Pro candle replay with simulated entries, stops, targets and manual closes, plus private saved practice sessions, P&L and R charts. Spread, slippage and fee assumptions are explicit. Practice stays separate from real trades. Provider coverage and retention vary.
CybillAI guide →Edgewonk
Trade-management analysis and entry/exit review are described. Confirm historical candle replay coverage separately.
Trade-management reviewWhich plan includes the new tools?
Pro + Realtime Trade Analysis includes the Pro journal tools. The Free journal allows up to 30 saved trades.
FeatureFree journalPro journal
Automatic tags & Discipline Review
Saved-data tags and evidence-led review; AI note tags require relevant notes and completed analysis.
Free: Included
Pro: Included
Weekly reviews
Account-saved notes, checklists, visual review and export.
Free: Included
Pro: Included
Risk & execution records
Historical R needs the original risk budget; imported P&L is preserved.
Free: Within 30-trade limit
Pro: Included
Private mentor workspace
Explicitly select records to share and revoke access when needed.
Free: Accepted connection
Pro: Accepted connection
AI coaching conversations
Follow-up chat and on-demand trade analysis. Automatic journal tags and review tools remain available on Free.
Free: Pro required
Pro: Included
Market volume research
Reported data for supported instruments; provider timestamps and coverage apply.
Free: Pro required
Pro: Included
TradingView webhook analysis
The paid add-on is required for alert intake and AI signal review.
Free: Add-on required
Pro: Pro + Realtime Trade Analysis
Visual playbooks
Private screenshots, annotations, rules and actual strategy results.
Free: Pro required
Pro: Included
Side-by-side comparisons
Compare strategies, accounts and periods through P&L, outcomes, R and behaviour charts.
Free: Pro required
Pro: Included
Replay practice
Simulated entries, stops and targets; saved practice sessions and P&L/R charts.
Free: Pro required
Pro: Included
Practice stays separate from real trade statistics. Historical prices, intervals and volume depend on the provider. Realtime Trade Analysis with TradingView webhooks requires its separate add-on entitlement.
Check your data and plan before moving
- Confirm broker sync, import formats and historical coverage for your account.
- Check recorded P&L, fees, currency, entry/exit times and timezone after importing.
- Historical R-multiples require original risk. A summary trade does not supply a complete partial-fill ledger.
- Reference replay and volume availability vary by instrument, provider and date. They do not establish exact broker execution quality.
- Compare current subscription limits, export options and the permissions of anyone reviewing your records.
- Weekly checklist and goal completion are manually recorded; neither promises improved trading results.
Common questions
Are weekly reviews and mentor workspaces included in these comparisons?
Yes. CybillAI’s weekly review saves notes and checklists to your account. Its private mentor workspace requires an accepted connection and an explicit sharing selection. Complete playbooks include their screenshots and notes; access can be revoked.
Does this comparison guarantee every instrument has replay or volume data?
No. Replay Practice models discretionary decisions from supplied candles; it is not an automated strategy backtester. Journal imports and historical market data are different sources. Confirm symbol mapping, timestamps, supported intervals and provider coverage for the instruments and dates you need.